Gilbert Pizza Reviews - Find Pizza in Gilbert, AZ

1

Nicantonis

1430 W Warner Rd Ste 136, Gilbert, AZ 85233

(480) 892-2234

"Best New York Style Pizza in Gilbert!"Not only is the pizza amazing but so is the stromboli! I've been going to this little restaurant for over 7 years and have never had a bad experience. Great food and great service!

- Sun Jul 29, 2012see all 42 votes

"NICANDTONI'S PIZZA"The worst pizza I have ever had in my life. The sauce was beyond boring, the toppings had no flavor whatsoever! The crust was burnt and when I called to ask if it was normal, they said "YES"! Thanks for the cardboard! Even though we paid ...

- Fri Feb 29, 2008see all 42 votes

55%

(?)

42 Votes

2

Gilbert Pizza

1150 S Gilbert Rd Ste 106, Gilbert, AZ 85296

(480) 633-2226

"Awesome!"So Good!!!

- Scott CMon Aug 08, 2011see all 15 votes

"My family and I are always trying..."to find NY/NJ style food. We often see pizza places say "NY Style" when its not even close. We figured we would try this place out. Everyone that works there is friendly and the place is always packed. Their pizza is amazing! It is just like the East Coast. ...

- Thu Jun 18, 2009see all 15 votes

54%

(?)

15 Votes

3

Papa Murphys Take 'N' Bake Pizza

1385 E Warner Rd, Gilbert, AZ 85296

(480) 632-7171

"Great pizza!"Love this concept!! I love that I can make a pizza anyway i want and take it home -and it never gets cold!!!

- Karly FWed Mar 28, 2012see all 2 votes

53%

(?)

2 Votes

4

Casanova Brothers Pizza

Gilbert, AZ 85234

(480) 539-6200

"Take me Home, Mama Mia"Fuhgededdaboudit, by far the best Pizza that I have had since I left the Big Apple. Tony, Mike, Luigi and the rest of the gang make you feel right at home ",NY" style. Man I am hooked and have to have my fix at least once a week.Just takes me back home whenever I go in. Every bite is just unbelieveable. Now I 'm getting hungry for the Bros again. I might have to go in and have a slice today....

- Deeg DThu Sep 16, 2010see all 17 votes

53%

(?)

17 Votes

5

Salernos Pizza

3921 E Guadalupe Rd 9, Gilbert, AZ 85234

(480) 892-0040

"Salerno's Pizza by The Phat Tyers *. at InsiderPages "Absolutely the BEST!!! We loved this pizza. I also happen to think they have the best Fettucini Carbonara in the valley. Not to mention their red sauce rocks, we have tried several pasta dishes as well as the chicken parm and Salerno's cannot be beat. Please take this from 2 people who LOVE to EAT. We are very sad that Salerno's has closed their dining room & are only available for take out &...

- Tue Jan 13, 2009see all 6 votes

50%

(?)

6 Votes

6

Oreganos Pizza Bistro

328 N Gilbert Rd, Gilbert, AZ 85234

(480) 882-9336

"Delicious!!!!"Oreganos Pizza is the best I have ever eaten. The layout plan is designed in a great fashion. Oreganos is a great place for friends and family to get together, eat and have a drink. The parking is also conveinent with easy access to the restaurant for all.

- Wed Feb 23, 2011see all 14 votes

"I don't care for the food at all"They use some seasoning, it seems like in every single dish. I can't figure out what it is, but I don't care for it at all. Have tried Oregano's several times, pizzas and pasta dishes. I just don't like it. I don't understand the big deal and the huge wait they always have. There are other great places to go, we won't go back.

- Fri Apr 11, 2008see all 14 votes

50%

(?)

14 Votes

7

Floridino's Pizza

50 E Guadalupe Rd, Gilbert, AZ 85234

(480) 539-1079

"Greatest Italian food by Caleb G. at InsiderPages "This restaurant is our favorite place to eat Ever!! I try to take my girfriend to different places but where ever we go we cant find food as good as floridinos.. we love their calzones.. and their mama's salmon is to die for.. Hospitality is 1st class its all family nd they are very welcoming. Excellent place!!! i recommend everyone to at least go nd try it once you'll be satisfied

- Wed Sep 17, 2008see all 5 votes

50%

(?)

5 Votes

8

Wings Pizza N Things

884 E Williams Field Rd, Gilbert, AZ 85295

(480) 722-9464

"great local hangout"great local hangout: good food good atmosphere has a neighborhood feel where everybody knows your name

- Sat Jun 23, 2007see all 3 votes

50%

(?)

3 Votes

9

Old World Pizza Kitchen

323 S Gilbert Rd, Gilbert, AZ 85296

(480) 633-6975

"Great pizza!"My wife and I stopped in here about 2 months ago and loved the pizza. Great little "hole in the wall" location. The restaurant itself is beautifully decorated, and the pizza is some of the best we've ever had. The desserts are pretty darn good, too. We're trying to bring as many friends as possible to enjoy the menu.‎

- Fri Feb 13, 2009see all 3 votes

50%

(?)

3 Votes

10

Prima Pizza

3611 E Baseline Rd Ste P2, Gilbert, AZ 85234

(480) 503-4444

"The best in the valley!!!‎"Prima Pizza is the best pizza in Arizona! I happened to find the place after needing to make an emergency food stop at the the nearby Taco Bell about 3 years ago. I saw the Pizza sign and went in to grab some ready made slices. My life has never been the same, I can't believe all the junk pizza I have been eating my entire life and calling it good. I have told all my friends and family...

- Sat May 22, 2010see all 5 votes

"Walking into Prima Pizza, you are hit..."with a kind of run down, old cafe style restaurant. Very plain decor, tables, booths. There is an old TV playing right inside the front door and the cooks are busy watching what they want. There are only 3-4 tables right there in the front of the restaurant and then more in the second, ...

- Tue Jun 23, 2009see all 5 votes

50%

(?)

5 Votes

11

NYPD Pizza Dept - East Gilbert

Serving the best pizza in AZ. Offering dine-in, delivery, online ordering, catering, lunch specials and weekly deals.

2743 S Williams Field & Market 2743 South Market Street 101, Gilbert, AZ 85295

(480) 782-6973

"Great pizza, good service"We went for a late lunch. Got a large pizza (it was HUGE). The pizza ended up on the floor mostly by my fault (took two slices off the same size, tipped over) and the made us another pizza no charge. Pizza was great and we enjoyed it for 3 days it was so much food.‎

- Tue Aug 18, 2009see all 3 votes

50%

(?)

3 Votes

12

Flancer's Cafe

610 N Gilbert Rd, Gilbert, AZ 85234

(480) 926-9077

Tags: Cafes

"Unique sandwiches- new one in Mesa! by shari m. at InsiderPages "Flancer's has a well-deserved reputation around Gilbert for their home-made bread used for a variety of unique sandwiches. Whenever a group of us teachers have a meeting day where we can go out to lunch, that is our first choice. I was excited to learn they just opened one closer to me in Mesa near Higley and McKellips.

- Mon Nov 10, 2008see all 4 votes

50%

(?)

4 Votes

13

Rosati's Pizza

8490 S Power Rd, Gilbert, AZ 85297

(480) 987-0888

"Eccellente!"Great food. Kind staff. Awesome atmosphere. Food tastes great and you get a lot of food for the amount of money you pay. Beer is expensive, but the food makes up for it. I've had a lot of items from their menu and have yet to be dissatisfied. There's something for everyone. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.

- Thu May 08, 2008see all 2 votes

50%

(?)

2 Votes

14

Pizza Hut

895 S Val Vista Dr Ste 104, Gilbert, AZ 85296

(480) 926-0935

Tags: Chicken, Onions, Pork, Soft Drinks, Carryout, Mushrooms, Breadsticks, Tomatoes, Pepperoni, Anchovies, Beef, Stuffed Crust Pizza, Ham, Italian Sausage, Jalapeno Poppers, Pineapple, Black Olives, Pizza, Buffalo

"Very good pizza! fast service and always has specials going on."Very good pizza! fast service and always has specials going on.

- Wed Oct 28, 2009see all 3 votes

50%

(?)

3 Votes

15

Rino D's Pizza & Wings

1515 N Gilbert Rd 114, Gilbert, AZ 85234

(480) 545-2700

"Great White Pizza"No doubt one of the best white pizzas I've had. If they had spinach as a topping I'd rate them even higher. Their wings are always fresh and moist tasting. If you haven't tried them yet, take a break away from the regular chians and enjoy. Check for their specials.

- Fri Jun 23, 2006see all 3 votes

"nastiest pizza i ever had by Emmanuel C. at InsiderPages "I recently visited this pizza establishment and it was not satisfied. the pizza took forever and was hardly worth it. and even worse they gave the wrong order. the crust was flavored. come on what ever happend to normal pizza. i was not pleased at all. the only reason i gave it 2 stars was cause they had a new girl so maybe it was her fault but i still dont reccomend.

- Wed Aug 03, 2005see all 3 votes

50%

(?)

3 Votes